• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
Legal123.com.au

Legal123.com.au

  • Individual Templates
    • Confidentiality Agreement (NDA)
    • Contractor Agreement
    • Copyright Infringement Notice
    • Disclaimer Templates
    • Holiday Rental Agreement
    • Letter of Demand
    • Power of Attorney
    • Privacy Policy
    • Privacy Policy GDPR Clauses
    • Trademark Registration
    • Website Contract
    • Will & Codicil
  • Legal Packages For
    • App Developers
    • Coaches
    • Consultants
    • Copywriters
    • Graphic Designers
    • Personal Trainers
    • Photographers
    • Property Managers
    • Web Developers
    • Website Legal Package [most popular]
  • Free Legal Guides
  • Contact

Do You Have a Valid Website Disclaimer?

Did you hear what happened to Zappos.com – one of the most successful websites in the world? Have you made the same mistake with your Website Disclaimer as they did?

In a recent US case Re Zappos.com (Sept 2012), there was a security breach by a hacker which resulted in Zappos being sued. Zappos wanted to arbitrate in accordance with their Terms and Conditions to save costs, rather than go to court.

But it was argued that their Terms and Conditions were invalid as they had:

  1. No user agreement with their customers, and
  2. No ‘click through agreement’ for the Terms and Conditions (where the requirement to arbitrate prior to going to court was an agreed procedure).

The startling result of this case is that the US court held that you cannot assume that users agree to your Terms and Conditions when they are buried in your website and there is no requirement to read them. In the Zappos case, the links to the Terms and Conditions were at the bottom of every web page – as is the standard for the majority of website businesses.

This case is an unusual and disconcerting potential precedent for all website and online business owners. It is basically stating a new principle that all visitors need to agree to Terms and Conditions before entering a site. In practice, it is not only unlikely they will actually read the Terms but is also a barrier to entry and doing business for all websites!

Past attempts to require active visitor agreement …

In the UK, they interpreted a recent EU directive on ‘cookies’ as requiring all visitors to a website to agree to accept ‘cookies’ in order to view the website.

Yet when the date of final compliance for all online businesses arrived in the UK, they realized this was not a real and commercial option for online businesses – plus they were the only EU country that interpreted the new regulations this strictly!

The result? The UK retracted the requirement to have visitors actively agree to ‘cookies’ and it’s now just a notification rather than active visitor acknowledgement.

But wait, there’s more …

As if that was not enough, US courts are now hinting that online businesses cannot state that their Terms and Conditions are “subject to change from time to time” but will require existing customers to re-read and accept any new Terms and Conditions.

This standard is very onerous and in practice would mean almost all website Terms and Conditions are considered potentially unenforceable.

One wonders if this is all another “shot across the bows” at Amazon, the owner of Zappos.com. Amazon has been under fire for “evading” sales taxes in various US States and have been forced to close distribution warehouses and discontinue affiliate relationships in order to keep their low prices. State Governments argue Amazon should be contributing more, particularly given the size of the business. And then maybe existing “bricks and mortar” businesses – under pressure with the slow economy – are lobbying to put pressure on Amazon and level the playing field.

Will Australia follow the US approach?

This US approach to online business and requirement for Terms and Conditions to be actively agreed to by visitors is not commercial and un-workable for online businesses. It will be seen as an impediment to business, just like the UK ‘cookies’ requirement, and if enforced, ensure online businesses move out of the US and set up elsewhere.

In addition, it is next to impossible to require any updates to Terms (often a requirement due to legislative changes) to be actively agreed and acknowledged by existing (or former) visitors and customers, as the case decision suggests. If you, as an online business owner, were to send out updates to any of your Terms and Conditions, how likely would it be that your customers would respond and agree?

Will Australia move in this direction? Its unlikely, in my view, that this approach is sustainable or that it will even be upheld in the US. It is not realistic contractual behaviour and it is unlikely to be followed by other courts or countries. Online business is bigger than ever and besides, no one goes into a physical store to agree to Terms before they shop, so why make that a condition of buying online?

How to protect your online business

One thing that you can do is check your Website Disclaimer and make sure that it has a clause stating that any visitor continuing to browse your website automatically agrees to your Terms and Conditions. Of course, here at Legal123, our Website Disclaimer template is up-to-date and has this provision. Why not update your Disclaimer and make sure you’re protected.

We’ve combined all the legal notices you’ll need to set up your online business (Privacy Policy, Disclaimers and Terms & Conditions) into one easy package:

Website Legal Package »

Published on 5 November 2012 Filed under Website Disclaimer

About Vanessa Emilio

Vanessa Emilio (BA Hons, LLB, ACIS, AGIA) is the Founder and CEO of Legal123.com.au and Practice Director of Legal123 Pty Ltd. Vanessa is a qualified Australian lawyer with more than 20 years experience in corporate, banking and trust law. Follow this link to read the full bio of Vanessa Emilio.

Primary Sidebar

Subscribe to the Legal123 Blog

Sign up for our free email updates about legal issues affecting online businesses, startups and everyday Australians.

Most Popular Templates

image of website legal template

Website Legal Package

image of app developer contract

App Developer Contract

image of contractor agreement template

Contractor Agreement Template

‘How To’ Guides

  • Do I Need a Will?
  • How to Avoid Copyright Infringement
  • How to Choose the Right Business Structure
  • How to Comply with GDPR
  • How to Develop an App: The Legal Issues
  • How to Divorce in Australia
  • How to Hire an Independent Contractor
  • How to Manage a Holiday Rental Property
  • How to Run an Online Forum
  • How to Set Up an App Business
  • How to Set Up an Online Business
  • How to Trademark Your Business Name
  • How to Write a Confidentiality Agreement
  • How to Write a Letter of Demand
  • How to Write a Power of Attorney
  • How to Write a Privacy Policy
  • How to Write a Shareholder Agreement
  • How to Write Terms and Conditions
  • How to Write a Will in Australia
  • Legal Guide for Bloggers
  • Legal Guide for Consultants
  • Legal Guide for Copywriters
  • Legal Guide for Graphic Designers
  • Legal Guide for Life Coaches and Mentors
  • Legal Guide for Personal Trainers
  • Legal Guide for Photographers
  • Legal Guide for Property Managers
  • Legal Guide for Social Media Marketers
  • Legal Guide for Web Developers
  • Legal Guide to Coronavirus (COVID-19)
  • What Legals Do I Need for My Website?
  • … More Articles in the Legal123 Blog

Blog Topics

  • App Developer Contract (1)
  • Confidentiality Agreement (2)
  • Contractor Agreement (4)
  • Copyright Infringement (1)
  • Email Disclaimer (6)
  • Legal FAQs (1)
  • Legal123 News (1)
  • Online Business Legals (1)
  • Online Startup (5)
  • Power of Attorney Form (1)
  • Selling Online (6)
  • Trademark Registration (3)
  • Website Disclaimer (5)
  • Website Privacy Policy (9)
  • Website Terms and Conditions (9)

Search Legal123

Footer

About Legal123

Legal123 was the first 100 per cent online law firm in AustraliaLegal123 is an Australian full-service law firm founded in 2009. We were the first 100% online law firm in Australia and are proud to be part of a growing movement to provide value-for-money legal services online. We offer both online legal templates and customised legal work. Our templates are designed for standard situations. We also do custom legal work for clients who have non-standard requirements or need legal advice. More »

(02) 8003 7317

[email protected]

9am - 5pm Mon. to Fri.

Sydney NSW Australia

Legal123.com.au

Free ‘How To’ Guides

Do I Need a Will?
How to Avoid Copyright Infringement
How to Choose the Right Business Structure
How to Comply with GDPR
How to Develop an App
How to Divorce in Australia
How to Hire an Independent Contractor
How to Manage a Holiday Rental Property
How to Run an Online Forum
How to Set Up an App Business
How to Set Up an Online Business
How to Trademark Your Business Name
How to Write a Confidentiality Agreement
How to Write a Letter of Demand
How to Write a Power of Attorney
How to Write a Privacy Policy
How to Write a Shareholder Agreement
How to Write Terms and Conditions
How to Write a Will in Australia
Legal Guide for Bloggers
Legal Guide for Consultants
Legal Guide for Copywriters
Legal Guide for Graphic Designers
Legal Guide for Life Coaches and Mentors
Legal Guide for Personal Trainers
Legal Guide for Photographers
Legal Guide for Property Managers
Legal Guide for Social Media Marketers
Legal Guide for Web Developers
Legal Guide to Coronavirus (COVID-19)
What Legals Do I Need for My Website?

Latest Articles

image of lessons learned starting online business
10 Lessons Learned from Starting an Online Business
are you accidentally sending spam
Are You Accidentally Sending Spam Email? You Need to Pass These 9 Tests
image of fake mcdonalds china
3 Things You Should Know About Business Names, Company Names and Trademarks
image of cybersquatting
Cybersquatting: Defending Your Brand Name Just Got Way More Complicated

© Copyright 2009 - 2021 · Registered Trademark of Legal123 Pty Ltd · ABN 66 153 012 269

We're Hiring · Join our Affiliate Program · Disclaimer · Privacy Policy · Terms & Conditions · Affiliate Terms

image of Law Society of NSW badge

Legal123 Pty Ltd is an Incorporated Legal Practice (ILP) registered with ASIC. Information and templates sold on Legal123.com.au are not legal advice. Use of this website is subject to the Disclaimer and Terms & Conditions. Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation.